The best alternatives to Fivestars
Fivestars is winding down into Clover Rewards. If you want to choose where you land, not just be migrated, here is what the alternatives actually look like.
Why businesses look for Fivestars alternatives
These are the pain points that push merchants to explore other options.
Fivestars is being merged into Clover Rewards. Active product development has stopped and merchants face a forced migration with no control over timing.
Customers must download the Fivestars consumer app to participate. This friction lowers enrollment rates compared to wallet-pass-based alternatives.
Running Fivestars requires a Clover or Fivestars terminal. You are locked to specific hardware regardless of what POS you actually want to use.
LoyaltyPass
- +
No customer app to download. Passes live in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet, the apps already on every phone.
- +
Actively developed: new features ship regularly on a platform that is not in wind-down mode.
- +
Works with any POS or no POS. Staff scan wallet passes with the free LoyaltyPass merchant app on any smartphone.
- +
Your customer data and loyalty history migrate with you. Export your Fivestars CSV and import it into LoyaltyPass with balances intact.
- +
$29/month all-in, with a 14-day free trial and no credit card required.
LoyaltyPass vs Fivestars: key differences
A quick side-by-side on the features that matter most.
Orange dot = LoyaltyPass advantage. All information based on publicly available data as of 2026.
Other Fivestars alternatives worth considering
LoyaltyPass is our recommendation, but the right pick depends on your situation. Here are three other options depending on your needs.
Loopy Loyalty
Businesses that want a simple, stable digital stamp card in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet without a consumer app.
Visit Loopy LoyaltyStamp Me
Businesses in AU/NZ or those that want a loyalty app option alongside digital wallet passes.
Visit Stamp MeClover Rewards
Businesses that are happy to move to Clover POS hardware and want loyalty built into the terminal checkout flow.
Visit Clover RewardsFrequently asked questions
- Is Fivestars shutting down?
- Clover (owned by Fiserv) acquired Fivestars in 2021 and is actively migrating Fivestars merchants to Clover Rewards. Active development has stopped. The product is not being switched off overnight, but merchants who stay will eventually be forced to move to Clover Rewards.
- Do I have to move to Clover Rewards, or can I choose a different platform?
- You are not required to move to Clover Rewards. You can export your Fivestars customer data and migrate to any loyalty platform before any forced transition deadline. Moving to LoyaltyPass lets you keep your customer history without buying Clover hardware.
- Will my customers lose their points if I switch away from Fivestars?
- No, if you act before losing access to your data. Export your customer list and point balances from Fivestars, import them into LoyaltyPass, and set each customer's starting balance to match their Fivestars total.
- What is the best Fivestars alternative for a coffee shop or restaurant?
- LoyaltyPass works well for both: stamp cards for coffee shops (10 coffees, 1 free) and points programs for restaurants. Both run in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet with no customer app download required.
- How soon should I migrate off Fivestars?
- The sooner the better. Once Fivestars locks down data access during the Clover migration, exporting your customer list becomes harder. Migrating on your own timeline, before any forced cutover, gives you control over the process.
Ready to try LoyaltyPass?
14-day free trial. No credit card required. Setup takes under 10 minutes.
Starting at $29/month · Apple Wallet & Google Wallet · No customer app required