The best alternatives to Toast Loyalty
Toast Loyalty ties your customer data to Toast POS and charges a percentage of sales. Here is what restaurant operators are switching to instead.
Why businesses look for Toast Loyalty alternatives
These are the pain points that push merchants to explore other options.
Toast Loyalty is locked to Toast POS. If you switch payment processors — even for pricing reasons — your entire loyalty program and customer history disappears. You are trading convenience for permanent dependency.
There are no branded loyalty cards in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet. Customers are identified by phone number at the terminal, which means no visual loyalty artifact, no push notifications, and no way for customers to engage with the program between visits.
Toast Loyalty is priced as a percentage add-on that scales with transaction volume, not a flat monthly fee. For busy restaurants, this can make it significantly more expensive than standalone alternatives.
LoyaltyPass
- +
Customers carry a fully branded loyalty card in Apple Wallet and Google Wallet — not a phone number lookup tied to a terminal.
- +
POS-independent: LoyaltyPass runs alongside Toast POS. Staff use the free merchant app to scan wallet passes. Nothing about your Toast setup changes.
- +
Push notifications included at $29/month flat — no percentage of sales, no add-ons required.
- +
Stamp card programs available. Toast Loyalty is points-only; LoyaltyPass supports both stamp cards and points.
- +
$29/month flat fee regardless of transaction volume. Easy to calculate and budget for.
LoyaltyPass vs Toast Loyalty: key differences
A quick side-by-side on the features that matter most.
Orange dot = LoyaltyPass advantage. All information based on publicly available data as of 2026.
Other Toast Loyalty alternatives worth considering
LoyaltyPass is our recommendation, but the right pick depends on your situation. Here are three other options depending on your needs.
Loopy Loyalty
Restaurants that want a simple wallet-pass stamp card without POS dependency — no consumer app download required.
Visit Loopy LoyaltyStamp Me
Restaurants in Australia and New Zealand that are comfortable with customers downloading a separate loyalty app.
Visit Stamp MeSquare Loyalty
Restaurants that are switching to Square POS and want loyalty built into the same ecosystem at the point of sale.
Visit Square LoyaltyFrequently asked questions
- Can I keep using Toast POS after switching loyalty platforms?
- Yes. LoyaltyPass runs completely independently of Toast POS. Toast handles your orders and payments; staff use the free LoyaltyPass merchant app on any smartphone to scan wallet passes and award points at the end of each transaction. Nothing about your Toast setup changes.
- What happens to my Toast Loyalty data if I switch?
- Export your customer loyalty data from Toast before switching. Toast Dashboard provides loyalty reports with member details and point balances. Import the CSV into LoyaltyPass so every customer starts with their existing balance — nobody resets to zero.
- Does Toast Loyalty issue Apple Wallet or Google Wallet passes?
- No. Toast Loyalty tracks points by matching a customer's phone number at the POS terminal. There is no digital or physical loyalty card for customers to carry or receive push notifications from. LoyaltyPass was built specifically around wallet pass technology.
- Is Toast Loyalty worth the cost for a small restaurant?
- Toast Loyalty charges a percentage of sales on top of a monthly base fee. For high-volume restaurants, this can add up to $100–300/month or more. For smaller restaurants, a flat-fee alternative like LoyaltyPass at $29/month with wallet passes and push notifications typically provides better value.
- What is the best loyalty program for restaurants not using Toast?
- LoyaltyPass works with any POS: Square, Clover, Lightspeed, Revel, or any other system. Staff scan customer wallet passes using the free merchant app on any phone. The loyalty program stays intact regardless of which POS you use or switch to in the future.
Ready to try LoyaltyPass?
14-day free trial. No credit card required. Setup takes under 10 minutes.
Starting at $29/month · Apple Wallet & Google Wallet · No customer app required